Tag Archive for: historical romance

You are here: / historical romance

Posts

In Defense of Historical Romance

/in /by

I didn’t study much history in school, and you won’t catch me reading a gazillion-page biography of Alexander Hamilton or anything, but I love learning about history through fiction (and by going to see the play, Hamilton). I think that’s one of the reasons I love historical romance: it gives me a glimpse of how people lived in another era.

Not that a romance written today is an accurate window into the lives and thoughts of Victorians, but seeing the past through the eyes of the present is part of the appeal. Some of my favorite romances offer delightfully revisionist versions of history.

I’ve been hearing for the past year or two that historical is dying and Harlequin shutting down its historical romance line seems to confirm that. But I don’t accept that historical romance is dead and I hope people keep writing it. So here’s my pitch for more, not less, historical romance.

A world unlike our own

My best guess as to why the market for historical romance is flagging, besides changing reader tastes, is that romantasy scratches the same itch. For readers who want to be transported to different worlds or times, romantasy is ready to fill that space.

But not all of us are into romantasy. When I want a world with different mores and struggles, I need rakish dukes and feisty proto-feminist ladies.

What the best historical romances do

As a writer, I’m very jealous of historical romance writers. Unlike contemporary writers, they don’t have to worry about whether the idioms they use will make their book feel dated two years from now. A good historical romance is evergreen.

As a reader, historical romances are my comfort food, with familiar obstacles and tropes — and sometimes the delightful subversion of those tropes. My favorite historicals reimagine history, with women who find ways to exercise power and agency in a world that tried to deny it to them.

Some favorite historical romances (a very incomplete list)

My favorite historical romance writer, and one of my favorite writers period, is Courtney Milan. Her Wedgeford Trials series imagines an English town where people of color live and thrive, where a half-Chinese duke does a bad job of keeping his identity secret, and quirky, inventive women rule. I’ve read all Milan’s books and they’re all great, but the ones set in Wedgeford are my favorites.

I read The Perks of Loving a Wallflower by Erica Ridley a while ago because it’s on a lot of queer romance lists. I liked it, but I didn’t realize it was part of a series until I picked up the book that preceded it. I read the whole series, including rereading the sapphic second book, and they’re better as a series. I love that Ridley has included characters with different experiences—different races, disabilities, and gender identity—in this delightful series. I recommend reading the series in order so there are no spoilers but I confess my favorite is Hot Earl Summer because Elizabeth Wynchester is hilariously bloodthirsty.

I’m a fan of Sarah Maclean, especially her bombshell series. Joanna Shupe explores the mores of Old New York, if you’re tired of England. I recently read some of Amanda Quick’s older books and they’re still great.

This just scratches the surface. Beverly Jenkins, India Holton, Vanessa Riley and many more authors have written wonderful historical romances.

What did I miss? I’d love your suggestions.

Queer representation in historical romance

In addition to The Perks of Loving a Wallflower, there’s a growing number of terrific books about queer love through history.

One of my favorite Courtney Milan books is The Pursuit of…, a prequel novella in her Worth Saga series. The main characters are a free Black man, traveling home from fighting in the Revolutionary War, which has just ended, and a White British soldier. Neither man is particularly safe traveling by foot through the newly formed country. Milan manages to inject humor without undercutting the gravity of their situation and the challenges they face.

Alexis Hall is one of my all-time favorite contemporary romcom authors. His historical novel, A Lady for a Duke, tells the story of a transgender woman who returns to the man who was once her best friend. The beauty of romance is that this is an uplifting story about the possibility for redemption and living as your true self when those who love you accept you, no matter what society says.

Most of Cat Sebastian’s historical novels are M/M romances set in the mid 1900s. They are wonderful, but my favorites of hers are her London Highwayman duo, The Queer Principles of Kit Webb and The Perfect Crimes of Marian Hayes. They are laugh-out-loud funny; I highly recommend them.

There are, happily, lots more queer historical romances. I look forward to discovering them. Recommendations welcome.

Bonus book: Naughty Nouns in Historical Romance

One of the members of my local romance writers group, Liz Adams, has recently released three books of historical words for romance writers. I don’t write historical romance, but I’ve been vastly enjoying Naughty Nouns in Historical Romance (it includes some verbs and includes more recent slang, too). Breasts might be referred to as “heavers” in 1674 and “bags” in 1770. For anyone looking for creative and historically accurate ways to write about sex, this is a great resource.

I’ve been in the writing trenches lately and getting behind on newsletters, but I hope to be more regular going forward, including some subscriber-only content I’m working on.

I started 2026 with grand plans to write a trope-heavy romance short story for subscribers every month and then everything changed, but not completely, for a variety of reasons. Which is a long-winded way of saying that I will offer special content to subscribers that will be completely awesome and you will be the first to know—but it’s going to take a bit longer to arrive than I originally expected.

Speaking of subscriptions, subscribing to my newsletter is one of the best ways to help me build my author platform, not only because you’ll get the latest information on what I’m writing, but also because it will make my first book (which is on submission now and it’s great, really, I’m not biased, you’re going to love it) more appealing to editors.

The Pros and Cons of the Author Binge

/in /by

Grooving on historical romcoms from Amanda Quick

I love an author binge. When I read a book by a new author I like, I want to find and read their complete backlist. This is partly because I’m greedy for more of the good stuff I got from this author, but also because I’m afraid I’ll forget them under the crush of my TBR pile.

However, reading too many books from one author back-to-back has its downsides, as I first discovered the summer I was 12.

Murder on the summer vacation: A cautionary tale about Agatha Christie

When I was 12, my family embarked on an 8-week vacation across Europe. It wasn’t possible to pack enough paperbacks to satisfy a voracious reader like me (this was before ereaders—yes, my young friends, there was a time when we had no choice but to read physical books—shudder). The only pre-teen appropriate author reliably available in English on the continent that summer was Agatha Christie.

I liked mysteries. I liked Agatha Christie—until I spent a whole summer mainlining her books. By the time we flew home from Amsterdam, I could tell you how every Christie book would end. I was bored to death with the scene where the detective gathers all the suspects in a parlor to reveal the culprit—so predictable. The red herrings, the real culprits—painfully obvious. Christie’s formula isn’t terrible; I just OD’d on it.

To this day, I’m reluctant even to watch a movie based on an Agatha Christie book. My author binge turned me off to one of the preeminent crime writers of the last century, and, honestly, that’s a shame.

My latest author binge: Amanda Quick

I recently grabbed three Amanda Quick novels written in the 90s, based on Reddit recommendations, and gobbled them down. Then I had a tiny bit of indigestion.

Mistress, Mystique, and Mischief are standalone historical romances. Mistress and Mischief are Regency romances; Mystique takes place in a Medieval period.

Despite the different settings and unrelated characters, I couldn’t help notice the throughlines that run through all three books: repressed heroes constrained by a strict set of personal rules and shaped by trauma; independent, feminist, chatty heroines unafraid to take matters into their own hands. I love those archetypes, but reading the books in the space of a few days, I couldn’t help noticing the patterns and the repetition of the grumpy/sunshine trope.

If I had read these Amanda Quick books as they came out, a year apart, I would have been delighted to dip back into her world once a year. The ecosystem of instant access and binge media consumption has changed the demands on authors to mix it up from book to book, while being similar enough that readers know what to expect from your author “brand.” I want to acknowledge that it is a big lift.

An author binge always works better for me with a series following the same or related characters. When I can follow characters I like through multiple adventures, I’m hooked no matter what. A binge helps me tease out connections in worlds constructed by the author or follow my favorite couple deeper into their happily ever after.

Book recommendation: Mischief

I liked all Amanda Quick books I read very much (and I will read more, after a break), but the one that stood out to me was Mischief. The heroine, Imogen, decides early on that the brooding hero, Colchester, has a delicate constitution. This is completely untrue, but he goes along with it in an indulgent and fond rather than mocking way. Imogen boldly sails through life, believing in a version of reality that makes her happy, and stepping up to protect the man she loves from becoming “overwrought.” I’m a sucker for an unreliable narrator, and I love that for her.

  • Humor level: Laugh out loud funny.
  • Spice level: 3 out of 5
  • Tropes: virgin, tortured hero, grumpy/sunshine, mystery

Amanda Quick is a pen name of Jayne Ann Krentz, who also writes under her own name and as Jayne Castle.

Writing updates

While my first finished book voyages through submissionland, I find myself starting and stopping too many other projects. My writer friends encouraged me to work on the second book in the series, which is sound advice, and I’m doing that, but there are so many other ideas crowding my head right now, I’m finding it hard to focus on one story.

That said, I am determined to finish a fun short story for you, dear subscribers, in the very near future. And, as always, let me know your romance recs.

Let’s Connect